As we age, certain daily activities can become more difficult and require accommodations to maintain independence. One such activity is using the toilet. For many seniors, bending down to reach a low toilet seat or struggling to stand up from a seated position can be a challenge. Fortunately, there are two common solutions to this problem: toilet seat risers and toilet extenders.
Toilet Seat Risers
Toilet seat risers are devices that attach to the top of your current toilet seat. They typically come in heights ranging from 2-6 inches and are made of materials such as plastic or metal. These devices are designed to make the toilet seat higher, allowing users to sit down and stand up with greater ease.
Pros:
- Easy to install: Toilet seat risers are typically very easy to install. They usually come with instructions and require no special tools. Some models may require you to remove the toilet seat, but this is a simple process that can be done in a few minutes.
- Cost-effective: Compared to other types of bathroom fixtures and accommodations, toilet seat risers are relatively inexpensive. Prices can range from around $20 to $100, depending on the model and features.
- Portable: Toilet seat risers can easily be removed and taken with you if you need to travel or move to a different home. This makes them a convenient option for those who frequently visit family or friends or spend time in different locations.
Cons:
- May not fit all toilets: Toilet seat risers are designed to fit most standard toilets, but there are some exceptions. If you have a unique or non-standard toilet, you may have difficulty finding a riser that fits properly.
- May not be sturdy enough: Some toilet seat risers are not very sturdy and may shift or wobble when in use. This can be dangerous for those with balance or mobility issues.
- May require additional cleaning: Some toilet seat risers have crevices or indentations that can collect dirt and bacteria. This may require additional cleaning to maintain proper hygiene.
Toilet Extenders
Toilet extenders, also known as commode seat extenders, are similar to toilet seat risers in that they raise the height of your toilet seat. However, instead of attaching to the top of your current seat, toilet extenders replace your current seat entirely. They typically come in heights ranging from 3-6 inches and are made of plastic or metal.
Toilet extenders are designed to provide a more permanent solution to toilet height issues. They are also useful for those who find standard toilet seats uncomfortable or too small. Some toilet extenders have a wider seat surface area, providing additional comfort and support.
Pros:
- More stable: Because toilet extenders replace your current toilet seat entirely, they are typically more stable and less likely to shift or wobble when in use.
- Easy to clean: Toilet extenders are typically easy to clean and maintain. Most models have a smooth surface that can be wiped down with a disinfectant wipe or cleaned with soap and water.
- Durable: Toilet extenders are designed to last for years with proper care and maintenance. They are made of sturdy materials that can withstand frequent use.
Cons:
- More expensive: Toilet extenders can be more expensive than toilet seat risers, with prices ranging from around $50 to $200.
- May not fit all toilets: Like toilet seat risers, toilet extenders may not fit all toilets. They are typically designed to fit standard toilets, so if you have a unique or non-standard toilet, you may have difficulty finding an extender that fits properly.
- Difficult to install: Toilet extenders can be more difficult to install than toilet seat risers. They typically require you to remove your current toilet seat and install the extender in its place. This may require special tools or professional installation.
Which is Better?
Deciding whether to use a toilet seat riser or a toilet extender ultimately depends on your individual needs and preferences. If you are looking for a cost-effective, portable solution that is easy to install, a toilet seat riser may be the best option for you. However, if you are looking for a more stable, durable, and permanent solution, a toilet extender may be a better choice.
Before making a decision, it is important to consider factors such as your toilet type, your level of mobility, and your budget. You may also want to consult with a healthcare professional or an occupational therapist for advice on which option would be best for your specific needs.
